Happy Birthday is a visually poetic portrait of a woman's inability to
establish a fruitful romantic relationship owing to a lack of a sense of
security.
A tragic love story can easily become a tear jearker, yet the director
handles the subject with tact and tries hard to move the audience with a
simple love story. Xiao Mi, influenced by her mother's sudden leave in her
childhood, becomes a vulnerable girl who lacks confidence and is easily
freaked out by the idea of loss. She is worried that her good-looking
boyfriend will break up with her one day and that's why she refuses to call
Xiao Nan her boyfriend. Her personality results in regrets...
Thanks to the Muji-like setting, the love story looks purer and more simple.
The white walls, the cream-coloured cushions, the beige teapoy, etc, may
linger in your mind when you leave the cinema. The props are also carefully
chosen to show the moving time. The soundtrack is more touching than the
movie and I love the theme song very much. It has been with me for several
nights. By the way, the setting and the characters' names also remind me of
another movie, Turn Left Turn Right. Fans of Jimmy, a famous Taiwanese
illustrator, may like this film!
The cast's performance is beyond my expectation. Rene Liu's finely
nuanced performance is much appreciated. Other supporting actors also act
naturally, though it is not convincing for Louis Koo to act a university
student when the wrinkles on his forehead can be obviously seen and Tsang Po
Yee slightly overacts.
Because of the moving trialer, I expected too much before watching the
movie. As a result, I was a bit disappointed owing to several reasons.
First, there is an unpredictable twist at the end, but it is not an original
one. I heard some people complain that the ending was old-fashioned. Second,
I feel little pity for Xiao Mi as it is SHE who proposes being his best
friend first and it is also SHE who regrets. If I were her, I won't announce
that I wanna change the relationship. Once she does so, she should know that
he can have another girlfriend and may even get married. Later, Mi even has
sex with Nam while she knows that he has a grilfriend in Hong Kong! After
TEN years, is it reasonable for Nam to get married with another woman when
she never calls Nam her boyfriend and she allows him to have another
girlfriend? Third, the first hour of the movie is a bit boring. Fourth, it
is a pity that Rene's voice is dubbed into Cantonese.
Although I personally find the plot mediocre and the ending slightly
disappointing, Rene's subtle performance, the Muji-like setting and those
memorable and delicate quotes deserve our praise.
Reviewed by: Kenji Chan