Yoji Yamada's Twilight Samurai is perhaps not the highest grossing Japanese film of
all time, but it is definitely one of the most successful ones. Having won so many awards
in the country, this 77th effort (reportedly) of the prolific director proves to be a
rewarding viewing experience. Although it does not have a very dramatic plot, nor are there
too many sword fight scenes, it nevertheless succeeds in grabbing the heart of the audience
with its charismatic and emotional story of a great father.
It is a realistic portrayal of a poor samurai called Seibei (Hiroyuki Sanada). Seibei's wife
has passed away at early age of their marriage and he has to take her part. He sacrifices all his leisure time to
take care of his two daughters and his senile mother. One day, his childhood girlfriend
Tomie (Rie Miyazawa) returns to the neighborhood after a failing marriage. The two of them
still love each other, but they are just too passive to say that out. Meanwhile, Seibei is
assigned a dangerous task. Before he departs, he decides to confess to Tomie... This story
is told in a very straightforward and simple manner. Director Yoji Yamada relies on a
very natural and linear cinematic approach to bring out Seibei's life. From Seibei's interaction with
his colleague to his daily life at home, and from the duel of the samurai to the confession of
Seibei, most of these scenes are realistic yet subtle. There are no
visually stunning composition or exotic editing at all. Everything just looks so plain and
calm. It is quite different from the typical Hong Kong or Hollywood films in which the
emotions of the characters are always blatantly presented.
The protagonist of this film, Seibei, is an appealing character. Although he is indigent and
his wife has died, he never actually feels despair. He never complains about his misfortune.
When the merchant refuses to buy his bamboo cage at a higher price, he just asks him to
consider it again, and then he keeps working as usual. At first glance, this character
seems to lack an ambition to strive for a better life, but if you see it from another
perspective, you'll eventually find out that what he looks for is not physical properties, but spiritual poessession. From
the dialogues as well as his behaviors in the movie, it clearly shows that to Seibei, the
most important asset is always his two daughters. An intact family is what this man cares
most. When every family member is at home, none of them looks unhappy.
They talk to each other, help each other and laugh happily. Aside from poverty, this is
actually a very pleasant and lovely family. Moreover, the addition of Tomie to the family
makes it even more complete by serving the long lost maternal position.
Excellent actings from Hiroyuki Sanada and Rie Miyazawa enhance the dramatic quality of
the film a lot. Sanada's composure does bestow life upon his character. A respectful
father is slowly built up piece by piece in the film. Rie Miyazawa does not share too much
screening time, but her character is so vulnerable and captivating and therefore wins the
heart of the audience easily. To a certain extent, Seibei and Tomie are almost perfect
in terms of morality, which I think is little too good to be true.
The two major topics raised in Twilight Samurai, family relationship and love, are
nothing new to the audience. What Yoji Yamada does is to merely display these pure and exquisite
qualities of human being in an honest manner. The reason why we love this film is because we are
emotional being. We always need encouragement to reassure our insecure faith in good human
nature, and that's what this film provides us.
Cool guy(s) - Hiroyuki Sanada, Rie Miyazawa
Reviewed by: Kantorates